«Санкции против правды»: Жак Бо о том, как ЕС ввёл против него санкции
Источник: https://scottritter.substack.com/p/sanctioning-truth
Краткое содержание
Вторая часть интервью Скотта Риттера с бывшим швейцарским разведчиком Жаком Бо, записанная в Брюсселе. Бо, 71 год, живёт в Бельгии и находится под санкциями Евросоюза, введёнными в конце 2025 года и продлёнными в 2026-м. Он рассказывает, чем занимался после отставки, как его обвинили в роли «рупора Кремля», что значат санкции для повседневной жизни и на какой стадии находится судебное оспаривание. Риттер подаёт всё это как историю о наказании за «правду» и в конце призывает американцев давить на политиков, включая вице-президента Вэнса. Версия Бо и Риттера — одна сторона; решение Совета ЕС и его мотивировка в беседе не приводятся.
Почему Бо стал писать об Украине
После отставки Бо издавал книги о разведке и борьбе с исламистским терроризмом. Он замечал, что «объяснять» в медиа приравнивают к «оправдывать» (так, по его словам, говорил министр внутренних дел Франции), хотя «intelligence» происходит от латинского intelligere — понимать; без понимания мышления врага нельзя выстроить стратегию. То же, по его мнению, произошло с Украиной после 2014 года: образ России формировали, не понимая её целей, и стратегия оказалась ошибочной. «Я предсказывал в 2014 году, что так проблему не решить; прошло 12 лет». С 2017 года, после ухода из НАТО, он начал книгу о конфликте. Бо рассказывает, что в НАТО увидел разницу между полковниками из «старой» Европы (Франция, Германия, Италия, Испания), мыслившими, как он, и коллегами из бывшей Восточной Европы. Он подчёркивает, что не связан с Россией и не судит, кто прав.
Методология и «ремесло» разведчика
Бо описывает приём оценки источников: буква A–F для надёжности источника и цифра 1–6 для достоверности информации; сомнительные «сочные» детали он отбрасывает или откладывает до подтверждения. Риттер противопоставляет разведчика журналисту: журналист даёт информацию на день, разведчик — полезный продукт. Бо говорит, что стремится объяснить, как каждая сторона понимает конфликт, потому что «обе считают себя правыми», а Запад привык решать, кто плох, и поэтому навязывает неосуществимые решения тому, кто побеждает; в швейцарской дипломатии «хорошее соглашение — когда обе стороны одинаково недовольны». Он рассказывает истории о том, что разведчик не принимает решений: его модель 1987 года показала сокращение сил Варшавского договора (отклонение от объявленных Горбачёвым цифр около 5000 человек), но начальство не верило, ведь в тот год Швейцария как раз закупала танки Leopard 2; в 1985 году он называл Горбачёва преемником Черненко — над ним смеялись.
Санкции: механизм и последствия
Бо говорит, что узнал о конфликте с системой только после санкций; официально его обвиняют в роли «рупора Кремля», причинно-следственная связь с заявлениями Кремля не доказана. Он утверждает, что никогда не говорил, будто Украина сама спровоцировала вторжение: он цитировал в «Операции Z» (конец 2022) бывшего советника Зеленского Алексея Арестовича как иллюстрацию того, как российская сторона воспринимает начало конфликта. (В тексте сказано «sanctioned in 2035» — очевидная оговорка/ошибка расшифровки, в другом месте Бо говорит о 2025 годе.)
Практические последствия: заморожены счета, он не получает пенсию, не может пользоваться картами; по его словам, представитель правительства Германии в ответ на вопрос журналиста о том, можно ли дать Бо хлеб, назвал даже это уголовно наказуемым. Запрещено «предоставлять ему ресурсы» (термин не определён). Формально ему запрещён въезд в ЕС, но он живёт в ЕС, поэтому, по судебной практике, ему нельзя перемещаться между странами; чтобы вернуться в Швейцарию, нужны разрешения Франции и Люксембурга, а нарушение превращает политическую санкцию в уголовное дело. Издатели во Франции, Германии и других странах держат гонорары на отдельных счетах до снятия санкций; сеть книжных магазинов Fnac во Франции, Бельгии и Швейцарии сняла его книги с продажи («Mein Kampf» продаётся, а Бо нет, замечает Риттер), остаётся Amazon.
Правовая сторона
Санкции, по Бо, — чисто политическое решение Совета ЕС (министров иностранных дел) на основе списка от службы высокого представителя Каи Каллас (около 5000 сотрудников); без суда, без права защиты заранее, без обвинения. Он предполагает, что его имя могло подать правительство Франции. Они нарушают Хартию основных прав ЕС: свободу слова, мнения, передвижения. Его адвокаты ведут обмен позициями в Суде ЕС (General Court); теперь начинается основная юридическая стадия. Бо цитирует переписку с Еврокомиссией: то, что он «нейтрален», делает его «ещё опаснее», потому что придаёт больший вес «российской речи». Обоснование санкций — «давление на правительство России»; Бо называет это абсурдом, поскольку он швейцарец, в России не был со времён до Путина и не связан с ним. Санкции открытые, без критериев снятия: «пожизненный срок под видом временной меры»; их продлили в 2026-м без слушаний. По словам Бо, Швейцария знала о решении заранее и не предупредила его; позже направила в ЕС ноту о несогласии со введением такой же меры из-за нарушения свободы слова и отсутствия процедуры, но, по Бо, это «алиби» без конкретных действий. Один читатель, по рассказу Бо, прогнал список источников его последней книги «Peace in Ukraine» через ChatGPT, и модель оценила её как сбалансированную и даже скорее в пользу Запада (довод не имеет доказательной силы).
Призыв Риттера
Риттер заявляет, что в деле «нет нюансов»: правы Бо, неправы санкции. Он просит американцев писать своим представителям и Вэнсу, говорит: «если они могут сделать это с одним, могут сделать со всеми». Бо сообщает, что у него нет сайта, он выступает в подкастах (Dialogue Works, Нимы Рахмани, Яна Праудa, итальянских и немецких). Адресаты для писем будут названы позже.
Значимость
Эпизод — публицистический кейс против санкционной практики ЕС в отношении граждан Европы: ключевые правовые вопросы (отсутствие процедуры, соразмерность, ограничение свободы слова и движения) реальны и оспариваются в суде. Но обвинение в «смертном приговоре», тезис «правда как повод для санкций» и утверждение, что ни один факт в книгах Бо не оспаривался, подаются без встречной позиции Совета ЕС и независимой проверки.
🧾 Транскрипт (формат)
Sanctioning Truth
Источник: https://scottritter.substack.com/p/sanctioning-truth
I'm here in Brussels, Belgium, in a wonderful home, interviewing a wonderful man, Jacques Baud. This is round two of the interview. We got to know you in round one. But, I mean, to be honest, if all I could do is come to Belgium to get to know you, it would have been worth it. But I'm here for another reason. And that's that today, as we sit here, you're under sanctions. From the European Union. And you're being sanctioned for basically speaking the truth. And so what I'd like to do is, again, just explore this a little bit more. Before we get to the actual sanctioning, I think when we left off last time, you retired and you chose to live in Belgium because you were used to it, because of the work, because of your friends, because of, you know, everything. What did you do after you left the military service that got the European Union so mad at you that they decided they needed to hit you with sanctions?
Well, I started, I mean, it's not that I started working, writing books. I have already written several books on intelligence and the way intelligence should be done, basically, on fighting terrorism, in particular, Islamist or Jihadi terrorism. And when I was writing those books and also when I wrote about intelligence and the relation between intelligence and fighting the struggle against terrorism, I understood that, or I noticed, better said, that what I as an intelligence officer would observe is not exactly what we see in the media. The way we portray the problem of terrorism is not exactly the way I see it based on my experience. And the problem is that we tend to, we tended, or that's what I observed at that time, that explaining was already excusing. That's, and by the way, the French Minister of Interior said exactly that. Explaining terrorism is already excusing terrorists. I said, well, that's completely stupid.
Explaining, I mean, and I come back to the word intelligence. Intelligence, the word intelligence comes from the Latin intelligere. Intellegere means to understand, meaning that intelligence is about understanding, essentially understanding a situation or understanding your enemy. That's what intelligence is about. And therefore, trying to make a distinction between explaining and trying to put together excusing that this is intellectually false. And I noticed that we have a lot of narrative that are probably, I mean, obviously portraying terrorists as bad guys, which they are, but not in a way that allows to build up a strategy to fight them. Because if you want to fight your enemy, an enemy terrorist as an example, you need You need to have a strategy, first of all. And to have a strategy, you have to understand how they think, how they behave, what is their mindset, what do they want to achieve, and so on and so forth.
And that's the only way then to build up your own strategy based on what your adversary is. And by Misunderstanding or not wanting to understand terrorists as they are. Well, we had misguided strategies and we failed to fight effectively against them. And I noticed also, and especially when the whole issue came in Ukraine in 2014 and so, I understand that Because we wanted to give a specific picture of the conflict in Ukraine, we were not able to address the problem as we should address it. And therefore, we needed to have a more, let's say, candid approach to the conflict to avoid a biased view. I noticed, but it's not, that was also prior to the conflict in Ukraine, but a lot of people still see the Russians as the Soviets. Even some people think they are still communists. So that happens too. But beyond the anecdote, We see that we don't understand what they want to achieve, what is the mindset, what is their objective, something like that.
We wanted to have our own understanding of what they are. I predicted already in 2014 that we will not solve the problem that way. And in fact, we are 12 years later today. And that proved correct because again, if you don't understand what's going on, you may have a narrative. You may have a story about the enemy, but, and that's fine as long as you keep it as a story. But if you want to build a strategy on this, Then it will fail because again, the strategy was what must be adjusted to your enemy. That's all. And in that spirit, I started to look at the different conflict and in particular, the one in Ukraine and to. We let's say. Try to have the most This is the most precise, the most factual picture of what is happening there. And that started when I left NATO, that was in 2017. I started right away to write about this. That was well before the actual conflict that started in 2022. Again, there was so many misconceptions, biased views, preconceived ideas that we were heading towards a major crisis that was obvious within NATO.
And interestingly, within NATO itself, as I said, I was in 2014 in NATO. And when I was talking to my colleagues, because I had obviously colleagues who were colonels also, my level, and I saw a distinct difference between those colonels who came from the so-called old Europe, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and those who came from the new Europe, as Donald Trump said. So that means former Eastern Europe. And you had very different views. And I noticed that those from the old Europe had the same understanding as me. So I said, there must be something wrong. And therefore, I started to write a book about this from 2017 onwards. The idea was to present a picture of the conflict that helps to solve the conflict. I have no family in Russia. I'm not Russian, obviously. I have no ties with Russia. I don't care about Who is what and all that. I'm just trying to do the job I did before to observe the conflict, to understand the whereabouts for both sides, and try to understand how we can solve that conflict.
That's all.
Now, it's curious. You said that early on in 2017, three years after Maidan, and we're already in two years into a NATO training mission in Ukraine, where old Europe is playing a role. And yet the mindset of your colleagues It seems to be different than the mindset that exists today. It was one of, how do we solve this problem? In the United States, we have a saying, again, in my marine training, you can't solve a problem unless you accurately define it. Exactly. If you don't accurately define the problem, whatever it is you're solving, you're solving nothing. Absolutely. And so you don't understand. So your approach... And again, I also think it's important to understand the difference between you, an intelligence officer, a well-rounded intelligence officer, and a journalist. Journalists deal with information. Intelligence officers make intelligence. And intelligence is a product that's useful.
Information... It's designed to seize a headline for a moment to sell newspapers or to broadcast, and then it goes away. And the quality is a completely different thing. So you're starting off your post-military career continuing the business of creating intelligence for the purpose of helping an audience that you're sympathetic with. The Western European audience, the friends, solve a problem that you had nothing to do with. You have no vested interest.
Absolutely. You're absolutely right. And you bring here an extent point here. You make this difference between information and intelligence. When you are an intelligence officer working, when you receive obviously information, What you do is basically you make two qualifications. You qualify the source and you qualify the information itself. And basically as a intelligence officer, you know that better than me, but you have a. When I was in intelligence, we had every single piece that we had, we had to qualify it. So you have a letter from A to F to qualify the source and you have a digit from one to six to qualify the information itself. And I use exactly the same methodology to assess, to use when I receive information. I qualify the source and I qualify the information. I discard information coming from sources that are not reliable. And, well, you know by experience also, and you also have websites that tell you which media is reliable or not, which is mostly factual or not, and things like this.
So this is not just... Something that comes from my head. It's something that is also recognized as a valuable source or reliable source. So I made that for every single piece of information I use. So it's exactly the same methodology that I use intelligence in order to have an accurate picture. And sometimes you have very juicy information that you have. We have that, and especially on social networks, you have suddenly this kind of small details. And here, then you look at the source and you say, well, that would look good in my book, but at the same time, The source is not reliable. So, well, you keep it for confirmation later or you discard it. And that's exactly the way I work. In order to have a product that I can say has intelligence quality in its content and its form. And that's the purpose, as you said, is to solve the issue is not to say who is good and who is bad. I'm not making a judgment.
I'm not trying to say who was right, who is wrong. It's not about this. It's about setting the not setting, but explaining how each party understands the situation. To understand, also to understand, to explain why each party acts like this or like that. In order for an external observer or an external actor even to say, well, if we want to solve the problem, then we have to deal in that direction or that because that whole A understands that or B understands that. And that's the essence. And I always wrote my books in the sense that that should be a help to solve the issue, not something to
judge people. Do you think you're your own, in retrospect, do you think you're your own worst enemy? And the reason why I say this is because you're producing an intelligence product. That had you been in the military or still the Swiss service would have been given to policymakers, that would have been a useful tool for them to solve a problem. What happens when policymakers don't want to solve the problem? When policymakers have a different agenda and now you're producing a tool that points to a solution they don't want to even consider. Do you think that this might have been...
Well, you know, that's a dilemma in which you are, even when you are an intelligence officer. You know, how many people in U.S. intelligence knew that there were no mass destruction weapons? Well, precisely. You know, you had people knowing that. And you know that at the end of the day...
But they could be silenced. See, there's the difference. If you were in active service... In the Swiss service, and you're producing intelligence, I could say, stop.
No, no, okay, okay. But from your perspective, as an intelligent, it's equally frustrating. That's the point. It's equally frustrating. But at the same time, well, you have, and that's part also of the problem in intelligence. You know the facts, you know that... Everything points at what you said. That was 1987. I told you that I graduated in econometrics. And in 1987, I made a model. Of the evolution of the Soviet Armored Forces based on the structure of the Armored Forces, based on demography, based on all that, the age structure of the Armored Forces, blah, blah, blah. And I made a projection that was, as I said, 1987. I made a projection through 1990, 1997, and 2000. And in that projection, I made different models of progression and estimate. I worked with a friend of mine who worked in the University of St. Gallen. And we computed the evolution. And we arrived to a model that the one I selected and I submitted to my bosses.
And I predicted that the Warsaw Pact would reduce their force by 1990 or 1995 by, I don't remember the figure exactly, but I predicted a number. And I gave that to my boss and they told me, Jacques Baud. You're joking. You're joking. They are not reducing. They will increase. They will improve. And in 1989, Gorbachev announced a reduction of the force of the Warsaw Pact and he announced the figures for 1995. And my projection for the whole Warsaw Pact was 5,000 guys away from the figure that Gorbachev announced. So we're extremely close to the fact, to the reduction, because that
was a reduction.
You know, nobody wanted to believe that at the time where in seven years, I mean, in 1987, because people, they don't believe because their judgment is based on their judgment, not on facts.
It's also based on budgets. Well, budget and all that, you have a
lot of factors.
You need a lot of enemy to build a lot of weapons.
Well, you are very much close to the truth because in 1987, that's exactly the time when the Switzerland decided to purchase the Leopard 2 tanks. That was investment of several billion of Swiss francs, and therefore nobody wanted to hear that the Soviets would reuse their voice, obviously. But that was the reality. And... So that's part of the and I think that's also part of the discipline or the, I would say, ethics of the intelligence. You have to accept that you are the one who provide elements for decision making, but you are not the decision maker and decision maker for good or bad reason may have other Consideration and may not accept even if you are factually correct. That's a reality and that's a reality that I think every indigenous officer acknowledges.
But it doesn't change the facts.
But it doesn't change the fact.
The policy decision does not change the fact.
That's correct. That's correct. But not later, you have the revenge of history. When you look back, then you can say, guys, you see, that's well, it's exactly the same thing happened, by the way. That reminds me, an interesting episode in 1985, as Chanyanko died. The Secretary General of the Communist Party in the Soviet Union. He died and nobody knew who would be the successor. And it was a lot of discussion within intelligence, not just in Switzerland, but everywhere to know who would be the successor. And I remember we had a briefing and a discussion on this topic in intelligence. And I said, well, you know, I have... My sources tell me that probably there is a guy named Gorbachev who could be the successor. And here I was just killed by everybody. Everybody told me, but who is Gorbachev? Jacques, please, shut up. Don't lose time with that.
Go back to the Sudan. We have a serious discussion here.
And just five days later, it was announced that Gorbachev would be the successor. And of course, I based that on a tiny publication that was made within the Party Communists of the Soviet Union at the time that pointed towards Gorbachev as a successor.
You mean a good source? A good source. With proven reliability?
Absolutely. But nobody wanted to believe that. Because that was not the conventional wisdom. So... And of course, then people felt sorry and they came and they brought me a bottle of wine and said, sorry for the other day, you were right and all that. But you have the revenge of history. Because the facts are not changed.
But in your case today, the revenge of history has been quite cruel. Well, that's true. Look, just so people understand, You've written books, wonderful books, and we'll be laying those out. And I think they've been published in English. And I think everybody should get these books, read these books to get a deeper understanding of not just who you are, but what you're saying. But you also, I first heard the name Jacques Baud, In reference, you would be interviewed by people and you would talk and people would call me and say, you got to listen to this guy. He's different. Because I have to tell you, I'm tired of having people call me up and say, this guy, you got to listen to the guy. He's an intelligence officer. As soon as I hear that, I say, I don't want to listen to him. Because as we talked before, these are people with a narrow spectrum talking about the things. And I'm like, nah. But you were different.
I'm going, wait a minute. This guy knows. It's deep and all that. When did it become clear to you that the system was in disagreement with you? I mean, because early on, as you said, your colleagues in Germany and France, your peers, you were of the same boat. You wanted to solve a problem. At what point in time did you realize that they didn't want to solve this problem, that you weren't part of the solution, you were becoming the problem?
Well, it's an interesting question. In fact, I realized this After I was sanctioned.
Really?
Absolutely no reward. So it took you by surprise? I understood that people had not the same view as me, but I didn't anticipate that people would see that as so threatening that I should be sanctioned.
Let's talk about the sanction, because this is important. It took you totally by surprise.
Totally.
So one day you're Jacques Baud in Brussels. A well-regarded analyst, a noted author, and you're telling the truth. I mean, no one, it's not like somebody's going up going, Jacques's full of it. All right. I mean, he's saying this, but you know, boom, boom, boom, boom. No one's saying that you're factually wrong. No one's doing anything or accusing you of, no one accused you of taking Russian money. You weren't traveling to Russia. You were in Brussels and suddenly sanctioned out of the blue.
Absolutely. Absolutely.
Now, what did they accuse you of in the sanction? I mean, where did this come from then? If there's no... Because normally, if you're going to get hit with something, you have an indication, like a phone call or someone knocking the door or a note saying, hey, Jacques, you might want to tone it down a little bit. But this came out of the blue. So what did they accuse you of? What is it that you were doing that...
Well, officially, I'm accused of being the mouthpiece of the Kremlin. That's essentially what they accused me of.
Have they made any, for instance, did they say, okay, Dmitry Peshkov said this, and a day later, you said the exact same thing. Have they made that causal relationship?
No, no, no, no, not even, not even, not even. They never demonstrated that. I always reported, for instance, some people said, I said that Ukraine engineered its own invasion or things like this, which I have never said, but I quoted Alexey Arrestovich, who used to be the advisor of Zelensky, who said something like this. And I explained that not as my own view, But as what the Russians perceive about the start of the conflict. Because I thought that it was important to understand how the Russians understand the conflict. That's the whole thing. I never said that it was how that happened. I said that's the way the Russians perceive it happened. Because at the end of the day, they are waging the war, not me. You know, I don't really care how it started. The important is to understand how both sides understand each other and understand the conflict. So for me, and if you read my book…
Which book in particular did the Arrestovich quote come from?
That was mentioned in Operation Z, and I use that quote in several books, but the first one was Operation Z, obviously, and it's a book that was published end of 2022. Interestingly, I was sanctioned in 2035, not in 2022, by the way. That's so interesting. But anyway, the interesting thing is that, again, the purpose was to explain how the Russians understand the conflict. And again, how do Ukraine understand that? And this is the confrontation of those two understandings that eventually makes the conflict. And that also gives a clue what could be the pressure point for an external...
And again, you're approaching this not as a partisan. You're not taking sides. You're approaching this using the same methodology, the same approach that you developed in a career as a career intelligence officer serving the United Nations, serving NATO.
And it's, by the way, if you read all the introduction of all my books, I explain that, explain exactly that. I'm not taking sides. I don't care who is good and who is bad, who wins, who will win, who wants to win. I also depart from the idea that when you have a conflict, and I've seen that myself when I was in Africa, when you have a conflict, from outside you can say this one is right, this one is wrong. But those who fight, they both think they are right. Nobody would die for something they think is right or wrong. So both sides think they are right. And that's a difficulty. And here in the West, especially when it comes to all these conflicts, by the way, you can name Palestine, Iran, we tend to make our own judgment. We say, he's right, he is wrong. And therefore, he's wrong, so he must lose. That's basically the idea. The reality is not exactly that. Both think they're right, and it may be that the one you think is wrong He's in fact the most powerful, which gives, of course, another flavor to what you could call an agreement or peace.
And that's exactly what the Europeans are experiencing these days because they want to come with a solution. And obviously the one who is targeted by the solution, if I can use the word targeted, is the one who is winning. Therefore, you want to impose something that you know is unachievable. And that's exactly the limits of the current Western approach to conflict. We need to address those conflicts in a more candid way. Without making any judgment, judgment will come later. But if you want to solve the conflict, then you have to see what is at stake for this one, what is at stake for that one, and to see a way where both parties Can, let's say, commonly disagree. We used to say in Switzerland, in the foreign affairs, we used to say a good agreement is when both parties are dissatisfied by the agreement, equally dissatisfied. And that's where we should, that's where we need to aim at. But again, we We don't do that because we are convinced that the bad guys have to lose and therefore everything has to be directed as this.
Now, when you were sanctioned, was it a slap on the wrist? Did they come up and say, Jacques, shame on you, bad boy, or what exactly? I'm being facetious here because I don't think people fully comprehend What happened to you? One day, you're living your life, publishing your books, speaking, earning a living, you have a pension, you're able to go to restaurants, you're able to travel. And the next day?
The next day, your bank accounts are frozen and I cannot receive my pension and you cannot even buy food. So you can't buy anything because obviously your credit cards are blocked and your bank account is blocked. So basically you can't buy anything from one day to another. Unfortunately, you have people who then help you.
But the law is not built on the premise that somebody is going to come and
help you. Correct. I would say even that those who help me could be criminally punished. So even a German journalist asked to the German government about me, by the way, interestingly enough, that was in Germany, Berlin. And that was earlier this year, I think, or that was probably end of 2025. Any case, he asked the German government if it's allowed to support me. And he said, is it allowed to give him bread? And the representative of the German government, and you can find it on YouTube, the representative of the German government said, well, even giving bread is a criminal act.
So you're supposed to starve to death? Die of exposure? How do you pay rent?
Well, that's a good question. And this is the problem. Basically, you are out and out. If you go strictly to what the representative of the German government said, in fact, you could even derive from this that you're condemned to death.
It sounds like they condemned you to die. For what crime again? What crime did you commit? Have you been charged with a crime?
Well, there is absolutely no judicial judgment or legal charge on that. It's a political charge. The sanctions are purely political. It's a decision that is taken by the Council of the European Union. I mean, the foreign ministers of the European Union. There is no legal authority. There is no judge, no tribunal. I've never been in front of a court. I never had the opportunity to defend myself beforehand. I never had the opportunity to have a lawyer representing me beforehand. All that was not. It's a political decision.
To put this in terms for Americans, You've committed no crime?
There is absolutely not a single law in Europe and probably in the world, by the way. There is not a single law that I broke.
Did you have a chance to confront your accusers? No. Did you know who your accusers are?
Not really, because in fact this is the Council of the European Union.
And what is the Council of the European Union?
Well, again, this is the assembly of the foreign ministers of the European Union. They received a list of people that would be sanctioned. And who made that list? This is the... This is the European Union. This is the office depending from Kayakalas. And Kayakalas is? There is no function as minister in the European Union. This is the high representative for external action of the European Union. It's the equivalent of a foreign minister, if you want. And her services established that list.
So within, you got Kayakalas, she's the Minister of Foreign Affairs, and
she prepares the meeting.
But she has underneath her a staff.
Correct. 5,000 people, by the way. How many? 5,000. That's a big staff.
And then within that staff, there's an Office of Sanctions. Correct. And within the Office of Sanctions, a faceless bureaucrat Decided to put your name on a list to condemn you to death.
Probably, but again, there is no proof of that, but probably my name was brought to the attention of the European Union by the French government.
And what did you do against the French?
Nothing.
No, you wrote a book. You wrote a book that solved a problem that the French didn't want solved. That's something I guess. So you went on a podcast and you explained things in a way that was inconvenient to the French. So you, and again, this is just a fundamental thing. I apologize because this is me interviewing you. But I'm an American and I'm shocked by this because we have freedom of speech in America. Okay, we have it. But you can't jump up in a fire, you know, in a theater. It's a famous thing. You can't shout fire in a crowded theater. You don't have the free speech to do that. But, you know, you have the free speech, if you're a member of the Ku Klux Klan, to hold a demonstration in an all-black town and wear things that are insulting and insulting. I mean, things that are hateful, but that's freedom of speech. You're allowed to do that. But it doesn't mean that you're right. Freedom of speech does not incur privilege other than free speech.
It doesn't mean that you're right. You don't get any moral status from this. You can express yourself freely and people can say, but you're wrong. You're wrong. I disagree with you, this, that. It encourages debate, dialogue, and discussion. And society has become stronger when we have these debates. When you call out, you're wrong, and this is why you're wrong. And the people get to hear the battle of ideas. And people get to decide this is a better idea than this. This one, that's freedom of speech. You aren't the Ku Klux Klan. You're not standing in the middle of an all-black township in Alabama wearing the white robes and burning a cross. You are one of the most experienced intelligence officers in the world who has produced nothing but high-quality fact-based intelligence, not information. You're not a whisperer from the New York Times. You're an intelligence officer. And somebody in France decided that you needed to be shut up.
France. Egalité, liberté. I mean, France, home of democracy, they say, modern. Somebody in France decided you needed to be shut up. So they went to a faceless bureaucrat in the office of an official who has what function? We don't know. No legal powers. And they condemned you to death because that's what they did. They debanked you. I've been debanked. I understand. There's no more helpless feeling in the world to wake up one morning and not have access to your money and to go, what do I do? Because there's no plan B. There's no plan B. You're just, boom. And then they can't feed you. They can't give you bread.
You're a dead man walking. In fact, this is so. It's forbidden to provide me with resources. Whatever the word resources means, because this is not defined. And in addition to that, I'm not allowed to travel. I mean, in theory, I'm not allowed to enter the EU. But funnily enough, they didn't realize that I was living in the EU. You're already in the EU. Exactly. So that also shows how they didn't know my case at all. But they decided, Jacobo, okay, so then they discovered that I'm living in the EU. So then there is some jurisprudence that says that if you're already living in the EU, then that means you cannot move within the EU, meaning that I'm not allowed to go back to my home country. If I had an issue in, for instance, if I have a problem with my family or so, I would not be allowed to go back to Switzerland. I should ask an exemption by the French government because I have to cross the French territory.
The territory of Luxembourg or both, because if I want to go back to Switzerland by car, I have to cross Luxembourg. So I need to have the authorization of Luxembourg. Then I cross the border of France. So I need to have authorization of France. And if I don't do that, if I'm caught, then the sanction from a political punishment become a criminal case. Technically, it would probably be possible to go by car to Switzerland because there is no border with Schengen. Basically, probably I could manage to go back to Switzerland. But if anyone recognized me during my travel, I could be charged with a criminal case because I'm trying to bypass the EU sanctions. And that's a criminal case. That means that my case becomes even worse.
Are you familiar with the phrase catch-22?
Well, that's exactly it.
You are in a catch-22.
It's exactly that.
And it's infuriating. I mean, as an American. But not just as an American, as a human being. I mean, look. We're both grownups. We've lived in a world where we know there's governments to do bad things to their people. There's dictatorships out there that abuse their people. And, you know, it's the state of the world. But to consider that Europe, the European Union, is doing things to you, which if a government... If Russia were to do this to one of its citizens, we would be screaming at the top of our lungs, how dare you treat him this way? You are inhuman, the inhumanity of it. And yet they're treating you, but you're not even treated like a criminal because you're not a criminal. No, I'm not. You're not accused of a crime. How did this accident happen? I mean, the legal aspects of it, how do you think they thought that you lived in Russia?
Well, I think they didn't, first of all, they didn't realize that was living in Europe.
Even though your books clearly say that you live in Europe. Absolutely. So they didn't even bother
reading your books. And even, probably not even the podcast, because I said it very often. The thing is that the sanctions, as sanctions, are meant as foreign policy measures. And it is a foreign policy measure, meaning that initially those sanctions were designed to sanction oligarchs elsewhere in Russia or terrorists elsewhere in Syria or so. Meaning that when you sanction people and you debank a terrorist in Syria, well, okay, you're not really affecting its human rights. The problem is that when you do the same thing in Europe, within Europe, You are then against a lot of laws and including, when we go at a European level, the Charter of the Fundamental Rights of Europe. And this Charter, which is a fundamental document of the European Union as it comes to human rights and the relations between European Union as an institution and the citizens. This is a fundamental charter and this charter has been completely breached by those sanctions because again, my freedom of speech is obviously harmed.
My freedom of opinion is breached. My freedom of movement is breached. My freedom of living Don't
you have a right to work under this?
I could work, but...
You can't get paid.
Exactly. So that's not work, it's slavery. That's slavery. Correct. You know, it's interesting because they didn't private me to write books, but I cannot get paid for that.
Just a curiosity. If I were a publisher and I wanted to publish a book, I would sign a contract with you.
Correct.
And in that contract, there's stipulations. You get so much residuals based upon this and the other thing. Could those residuals be put in? Is it legal for you to set up a trust account or are you not even allowed to do that?
Well, that's what my publishers are doing because I have a publisher in France, another one in Germany. And there are others in other parts of Europe, by the way, because my books have been translated in Polish, in Czech, in Swedish, German, and of course English, when it comes to Europe. And the publishers are, in fact, they cannot give me the money. They can keep it on a separate account. And when the sanctions will be lifted, then they can pay.
Do the sanctioners go after that money?
Well, that's an open question. Because, again, and for that reason, by the way, for instance, there is a... Bookshop or bookstore, very much like Barnes and Noble in the US. It's called Fnac in France. It's a huge bookstore. They redraw all my books from the shelves. They stopped. Selling my books because they say, well, we cannot provide you any resource and selling your books is already creating a resource for you. So we don't sell your books anymore. They are present in France. It's a French company. They are present in Belgium and in Switzerland. In all these three countries, they stopped selling my books. And some people have tried to order the book and they refused to order it. So the only way is Amazon. And again, we are back to a US company that is the only company that has made absolutely no problem selling my books because my books are not forbidden. They are legally not forbidden.
But neither is Mein Kampf. Correct.
Certainly we're not comparing your books with Mein Kampf, are we?
Well, FNAC is selling Mein Kampf, but not Jacques Baud.
So selling Adolf Hitler, but not Jacques Baud. Exactly. Correct. That shows exactly where we are.
Free speech. Exactly.
Adolf Hitler has free speech. Exactly. The right of free speech. Ladies and gentlemen, Adolf Hitler is protected free speech. Jacques Baud is not. Correct. Because you tell the truth. Exactly. The whole truth and not just the truth. You tell truth that isn't just information, but it's intelligence. And I think we have to, again, make this distinction. What makes you dangerous is that your information is actually actionable. Meaning that when someone reads your books, you are empowered with a level of knowledge and information and insight that enables you to make informed decisions.
Well, in fact, you're perfectly right to say so because the European Commission, in those exchanges between my lawyers and the European Commission, they said so. They said the fact is neutral is even more dangerous.
I'm sorry, let me laugh, but this is the catch-22. You have done nothing wrong. In fact, you're the perfect source. Jacques Baud is the perfect source of information. He is neutral, unbiased, fact-based, with an Analytical methodology that is well-rounded, grounded and experienced. You must take Jacques Baud's information seriously. Therefore, we must silence Jacques Baud.
Exactly. This is exactly that. And the European Union, in fact, acknowledges that because they say the fact is neutral is even more dangerous because that gives him more weight To the Russian speech. This is just amazing. We are exactly in this Catch-22 situation. How do you get
out of this? Because you have the European Human Rights Charter that's clearly linked. I believe there's a European court that protects human rights.
That's correct. So for now, just to explain the process for now, we had my lawyers, I mean, me and my lawyers had exchange of documents and arguments between me and the Council of the European Union through the what is called the General Court of the European Union. And From now on, we'll change and we have to go into the real legal procedure. And that's where the court has to decide whether my situation is legally justifiable or not. And then we go, we haven't, we had legal argument, but it was only, how to say that, The position of my position versus the position of the council. And we have explained our position, respective positions. But from now on, we'll have to debate on that, to discuss that. And the real work, the real legal work will come from now on.
But you have never been to trial? Never. There's no convictions?
Absolutely no.
But you're being punished as if you are convicted. Exactly. Can this court, does it have the latitude to say, Jacques, we suspend a sentence that really doesn't exist, but we suspend the sanctions in lieu of a review. Can the court suspend the sanctions? Well, they could. Why don't they?
Well, they could, but even the council could say, okay, well, Considering all the aspects, we noticed that Jacques Bo was not a propagandist and things like this. But the problem is that we all know the European Union is a situation. And I think, as we discussed before, these sanctions came in 2025, not in 2022. Because in 2022, everybody was very... Optimistic about the success of Ukraine and the failure and defeat of Russia. But in 2025, the things have changed dramatically.
And even more today.
And even more today. Which makes you as a neutral expert very dangerous. Very much dangerous.
We have to keep the sanctions on.
Exactly. This is exactly the problem. Because today the European Union understands that with time... We see that, first of all, what I said was correct. Not a single fact that has been mentioned in my book has been objected. Not a single fact. They are all perfectly based and mostly, by the way, it's interesting because recently a reader of mine took my last book, which is Peace in Ukraine, and took All the footnotes, I mean all the sources, only the sources, scanned all them and submitted all the sources to ChatGPT and asked ChatGPT to make an assessment of the book based on the sources only. And Chad GPD came with the assessment that it was a very much balanced and honest book, even a little bit in favor of the West. This is just no offense,
don't take me wrong, but you are so neutral and so fair and so balanced that the West actually gets the benefit of the doubt oftentimes, meaning that your analysis actually favors the West more than it favors Russia. And the concept that you're a Russian propagandist is absurd. Can you countersue? For instance, I would imagine when you have a charter of human rights that infers rights upon a person, so if they feel wrong, they have the ability to confront through the court of law. You have been sentenced to death. You have had your money seized. You have had every crime imaginable committed against you by the European Union. I don't want to go too deep into that, but I can. One of the reasons why people at that level do what they do is there's no fear of repercussions. There's no fear of, no accountability.
There's no accountability at all.
And the moment you establish a modicum of accountability, suddenly people's behavior changes somewhat.
That's also what I think.
Okay. Look, I do need to point out that you're in the middle of a Literally a legal fight for your life. Exactly. Let's not be overdramatic here. If they wanted to, they could deny you the ability, not just to receive money, but to starve you to death, to deny you shelter. Anybody who provides assistance to you, whatever, out of the kindness of their heart or humanity, could become criminalized for violating the sanctions. So we are literally talking about the fight of your life here. And it's being done in a court system that doesn't appear to be... First of all, it's not timely. I mean, the concept of speedy justice doesn't exist here. They could extend this for as long as they want to. Absolutely. And there's no guarantee of justice because you're in a limbo. You're in this legal...
And you know, it's an open-ended system, meaning that when you get... You go to court because you speed up on the street or things like that. You know that you can be fined for something, for a thousand euro, dollars or whatever, or you can go to jail for one month or so, let's say. Here, this is unlimited. This is open-ended. It's not that you are sanctioned for One year, two years or so. It's recurring. It's a life sentence. It's a life sentence. And even though they say it's temporary, well, there is no criteria for this temporary. There is no criteria. What is the criteria to say that I'm not sanctioned anymore? There's no criteria. So it's open-ended. This could be a life... Fundamentally, it's a life sentence disguised as a temporary measure. But in fact, this is exactly what happened. I was sanctioned last year. And just this year, this was extended. But there is no reason. They didn't explain why they extended.
There's no hearing?
Absolutely not.
So there's no hearing. Your case was... Who extended it? Simply extended.
By the bureaucrats.
So a bureaucrat decided to continue your... I get a little personal here. How old are you? 71. You're 71 years of age. You appear to be in good health.
Well, yes, fortunately.
Fortunately. But the point is, look, I'm just a few years behind you. We've lived our lives, but that doesn't mean life's over. Correct. We're actually at the stage of life where we've earned the right To live. We've given society its due, and it's our time to, it's our golden years. And the European Union, European Commission, Calais Callas, some nameless bureaucrat, the French government, have decided that you're going to be denied that which we all work for in our lives. We work for this moment where we can sit back and say, This is it. I mean, how does this make you feel? This is, well, this is so absurd.
You know, if you go into the details, that makes that even more absurd. Because my lawyers ask why, what is the reason, in fact, to sanction me? And the response from the council is that I'm sanctioned to make pressure on the government of the refederation of Russia.
Ah.
So this is the rationale. This is to put pressure on Vladimir Putin. But you're good friends with Vladimir Putin.
You can call up Vladimir Putin and ask him, say, Mr. President, the last time I met with you... You said, if there's anything I can do to help you, call me. So I'm calling you, help me. Well, that's at least the representation
the European Union
has. Have you ever been to Russia?
I have been to Russia, but a long time ago, well before Vladimir Putin, by the way. I haven't been since he's in power, by the way. But this is funny to see this kind of childish representation they have. Because, you know, if you sanction an oligarch who maybe has ties with the government or even probably have leverage through money or whatever, then you can say some kind of rationale to have sanctions. But I'm Swiss. I have no connection with Russia whatsoever. I have not I'm sure that Vladimir Putin has probably knowledge of me since I'm sanctioned, but not before. The idea that sanctions on me would influence the government of Russia to stop the war in Ukraine. This is so absurd and so childish that you can really ask yourself about really if those people who make decision
This is a very important point because this is sort of their actions are self condemning, meaning if you want to make the case that these people shouldn't be allowed the privilege of governance, your case is exhibit one.
Exactly.
Why these people should never be allowed to govern ever because they Are incapable of rational thought. Everything about your case is irrational, 100%. Now, I'm going to bring up something. You mentioned, you said, I'm a Swiss citizen. Where is Switzerland in all of this? I mean, and I'm going to say from this point, because I'm speaking now to the Swiss government. This man's a hero. This man served your country loyally. This man did things that you asked him to do that nobody else had ever done before. Many of you might have thought he wouldn't have accomplished the job. He did it. He deserves medals around his neck, medals on his chest. He deserves to be given the privilege of acknowledgement. Where is the Swiss government?
It's a good question because, in fact, first, the Swiss government, apparently, they were informed about the decision beforehand. So that means they didn't object it.
And they didn't warn you either.
And they didn't warn me either. And so that's the first thing. And once, when the sanctions came late 2025, then of course some papers started to write about this and said, more or less what you said, that in fact the government, my government should be grateful and in fact should protect me. And then... Then the government realized, and I know, I don't want to give more details, but I know they realized that they failed in something. So they made a notification to the European Union saying that Switzerland would not take Over those sanctions against me because those sanctions were breaching my freedom of speech and because these sanctions were taken without a due process. So they sent that and An ambassador called me from Bern to say that the Swiss government has sent this demarche or note to the European Union. I said, and okay, that's fine, but are you doing anything to make sure that they do something?
I mean, is it just notification or are they doing something? So we are doing nothing about this. So the government has sent this notice just as an alibi, basically. But they will and they haven't done anything concrete so far. So far, I know.
Now, when you worked in your role as a Swiss citizen in the United Nations, did you ever have a diplomatic passport? Yes. And you do have a relationship in the past with the Swiss Foreign Ministry. I saw in your... Absolutely. Why can't they today say, Jacques, we have a special project for you, foreign ministry, and here's a diplomatic passport, come home. Could they do that?
Well, I mean, let's assuming they could, technically they probably could, but... First of all, knowing the people there, they're so bureaucrats that I don't expect that. But let's assume they would do it. It would not solve the problem because I would still be under sanction in the European Union. And the problem is not for me. If I would go to Switzerland, I would have my bank account in Switzerland available. But the problem is I'm not living there. You know, my furniture, my books, my life is here. So the thing is that, yes, I could probably travel to Switzerland, maybe find some arrangement, but it's not a solution to the problem.
It doesn't solve the problem.
Exactly.
And what we need here is a solution. We need full restoration of your rights. Yes. Rights that accrue to you. The way they accrue to every citizen of the European Union, in rights that cannot be taken from you because you have done nothing judicially that warrants the restrictions of your rights. I'm frustrated. I know you must be as well. This can't be an easy thing that you're going through. All I can say is, you know, thank you for your courage. Thank you for your determination to continue to tell the truth. I mean, it's amazing. You still write books. Where can people find you? If I were... Watching this, where can people go to find your works? Is there a website?
No, there's no website. I mean, I do regular interviews and things like this. I thought I should probably have a website, but again, I'm so... Busy with writing my books that I don't have any spare time to feed a blog or a vlog or something like that. Therefore, okay, I renounce to this. I contribute to some podcasts. That can be Dialog Works. That could be my publisher. That's Nima Rostrama. Nima, exactly. So you're a regular... Exactly. I'm a regular there. I'm also with Jan Proud, for instance, others also. I'm also in Italian because I speak Italian. So I'm also on some Italian podcast. I'm also on some Germans. I'm invited to some because I speak German as well. So but I don't have any place. And if people wanted to write letters, let's say we just
started a letter writing campaign. Who should they write letters to? What's the appropriate venue in Switzerland and who should be the recipient in the European Commission?
It's a good question. I have to look at this off record and probably we can discuss that and you could put some link. We'll discuss that off the record.
Absolutely. Well, look, first of all, I can guarantee you that this isn't an issue that's going to go away. Unfortunately for you anytime soon, but also for me, I'm committed to this. Thank you. I'm like a dog with a bone in my mouth. I'm just going to keep gnawing at it until we get a solution. But, Brock, I just want to say thank you very much for this.
Thank you, Scott, for coming.
Again, I just want to make an appeal to the audience here. There's right and there's wrong. Black and white. Oftentimes we live in a world that's defined by gray and there's a lot of nuance. On this one, there's literally no nuance. There is right. That is Jacques Baud. There is wrong. And it's the sanctions that have been imposed against him. And if you're an American who believes in free speech, understand this. We cannot allow our government to speak of the Europeans as people the way they're treating him. There must be a price to be paid for what's being done to Jacques Baud. I would encourage everybody to contact their elected representatives, to contact J.D. Vance, the vice president, who has been a staunch supporter of free speech. It's time to hold Europe accountable, because if they can do it to one, they can do it to all. The time, you know, we go back in American history, you know, if they want to have a fight, Let it begin here.
Let it be this cause. There's no more righteous cause than the cause of Jacques Baud and the crime that's being done to him. Thanks a lot for tuning in.